By Simrin Sirur

The proposal to include an agenda item focussed on the impacts of rising temperatures on high mountain ranges may have been rejected at the ongoing COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, but that hasn’t stopped the talks from spotlighting their catastrophic impacts — and the urgent need to address them. A special update by the World Meteorological Organisation estimates the Earth lost 400 gigatonnes of glacier ice in 2025.

The push for a stand-alone item dedicated to warming in the mountains was championed by Nepal, which in August suffered devastating flash floods caused by a rock-ice avalanche, along with Bhutan and Kyrgyzstan. The vulnerability of the high mountain ranges has been “underrepresented within the core decision-making tracks of the UNFCCC,” Nepal argued in its submission, adding that the COP31 provided an opportunity to integrate “mountain-specific priorities into adaptation, finance and loss-and-damage frameworks.”

Though the proposal was ultimately inched out of the formal agenda by competing interests — including a flagship proposal for electrification — its concerns are echoed in the COP31’s draft cover text, a strategic document summarising the summit’s priority areas, released on November 16.

“When the standalone agenda item, co-proposed with Bhutan, was not adopted, Nepal pivoted swiftly to mainstream cryosphere and mountain priorities across existing negotiating tracks. That diplomatic pivot is yielding concrete results,” Lila Pieters Yahia, Nepal’s UN Resident Coordinator, told Mongabay-India over email.

The draft cover text, which is likely to undergo several revisions before being finalised at the COP31’s conclusion on November 20, “recognises the particular vulnerability of mountain regions and glacier-dependent communities to the adverse effects of climate change,” and proposes work programmes dedicated to resilience building and the scientific understanding of these vulnerabilities.

But a dedicated focus on the issue requires consistent solidarity between developed and developing Parties, said Yahia. “Nepal is demonstrating strategic leadership in how to respond. The strongest expression of international solidarity would be to match that leadership with commensurate action, investment, and cooperation.”

A session on advancing the mountain agenda at COP31. Image by Kubilay Ciftci/UN Climate Change via Flickr (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).
A session on advancing the mountain agenda at COP31. Image by Kubilay Ciftci/UN Climate Change via Flickr (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

The cryosphere at 1.5°C

All the scientific literature points to a near-certain overshoot of global warming at 1.5°C — the lower bound of the Paris Agreement’s target. The latest UN Emissions Gap report says that the world is on track for 2.6°C of warming by the end of the century, even after countries fully implement their climate goals. Global sea surface temperatures have already exceeded 1 degree since pre-industrial times, and higher levels of warming are associated with greater climatic extremes, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has said.

For the cryosphere — the Earth’s frozen components — any further warming will lead to losses that are “irreversible on human timescales,” a new report by International Cryosphere Climate Initiative (ICCI) says. Global warming of 1.5°C would translate to an average warming of 1.8 to 2.2°C over the Hindu Kush Himalayan range, and if emissions remain at current levels, only 16% of Himalayan glaciers are likely to remain by the end of the century.

“Every government minister and every fossil fuel executive who’s ever succeeded in watering down climate action can look at this report and see how their actions have fundamentally damaged the world we live in,” said Bill Hare, CEO of the global science and policy institute Climate Analytics, in response to the report.

Losses from the cryosphere are likely to exacerbate water insecurity and trigger more floods from glacier collapse — as seen in Sikkim in 2023 and Bhutan in October this year. The implications are particularly pertinent to India, where 17% of landmass is covered by the Himalayas. Glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs), avalanches, and extreme weather events are already among the most common natural disasters afflicting states like Uttarakhand, Himachal Pradesh, and Arunachal Pradesh.

“It is really a policy failure that we’re moving into a period that will entail at least some overshoot,” Pam Pearson, director of the ICCI, told Mongabay-India. “But we’ve seen an incredible amount of discussion and impact from our report. It really seems to be breaking through that the cryosphere is different, and that should make overshoot in essence unacceptable.”

A temporary bridge erected in Punakha, Bhutan, following floods. Any further global warming will lead to losses for the Earth's cryosphere that are “irreversible on human timescales,” according to a new report by International Cryosphere Climate Initiative. Representative image by David Broad via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0).
A temporary bridge erected in Punakha, Bhutan, following floods. Any further global warming will lead to losses for the Earth’s cryosphere that are “irreversible on human timescales,” according to a new report by International Cryosphere Climate Initiative. Representative image by David Broad via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0).

A divisive agenda

World leaders took to the summit stage on November 12 to appeal for greater recognition of the particular vulnerabilities facing countries with high mountain ranges.

“Our new national inventory released this year shows that Bhutan now has 620 glacial lakes. That is more than 50 new lakes in just five years. Since 2018, we have lost 27 glaciers and about 9% of our glacial area. Every glacier we lose threatens us twice: first as a flood, and later as a running river,” said Sonam Tashi, Bhutan’s Director of the Department of Environment and Climate Change.

The push to include a “mountain agenda” as a distinct item of discussion has been largely unsuccessful over the last five or six years at the COPs, said Pearson. “I think there is a lot of support and interest in discussing these items, but there is some fear that these meetings have had so many new agenda items and discussions that the actual focus on things like mitigation, and on fulfilling the Paris Agreement, sometimes can get a bit diffused.”

The High Level segment, co-hosted by Nepal and Bhutan, saw greater participation from countries in the Global South, including Lesotho, Uzbekistan, and Pakistan. India, however, remained absent during the event.

Devastating floods in Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir. Image by Imad Clicks via Pexels.
Devastating floods damage buildings in Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir. Image by Imad Clicks via Pexels.

“What can we say about Europe and the commitment of Europe, where we, France and the UK, are the only representatives?” said Olivier Poivre d’Arvor, France’s Ambassador for the Poles and Maritime Affairs, who also noted the absence of India, China, the U.S., and Canada at the event. “All countries, from the beginning to the end of the chain, are concerned,” he added.

The fractious nature of the issue is revealed in the technical discussions of the COP’s Subsidiary Body, which notes that some Parties hesitate to support a “mountain agenda” because of “the additional financial, institutional and human resource demands associated,” while other Parties “emphasised that any such engagement should be Party-driven, facilitative and non-prescriptive, and that it should not entail new obligations or reporting requirements for Parties.”

Because of the transboundary nature of cryosphere-related disasters, a mountain-specific agenda could help strengthen regional networks, said Yahia. “Effective climate adaptation requires regional scientific solidarity, specifically open-access satellite and ground-based cryosphere monitoring, interoperable early warning systems, and cooperative river-basin governance,” she said.

It also requires streamlined channels of finance. Before the COP, Nepal appealed to the newly launched Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage for immediate funds to help communities recover from the August flash floods, which killed 1,400 people. The Fund agreed to provisionally approve $21 million — a fraction of the $4.71 billion it will cost to rebuild.

“Mountains remain underfunded and under-resourced,” said Bhutan’s Tashi during the high level event. “We call for grant-based and concessional adaptation funding, with simpler and faster access to small mountain countries,” he said.

With the growing frequency of such disasters becoming inescapable, attention is now on the cover text’s next revision. “It’s our hope that with a strong and robust cover decision, Parties will be motivated to take the action that is needed to protect the mountains, to protect cryosphere, to protect the low-lying areas that are going to be among those suffering, in addition to downstream nations from cryosphere loss, if we cause overshoot to go too high or to last too long,” said Pearson.

This article is republished from Mongabay under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article here.