Guwahati: The Calcutta High Court has dismissed the Mizoram government’s appeal against an earlier order directing it to complete the sale of its property at 24, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue in Kolkata to Excel Vincom Private Limited, describing the cancellation of the transaction after a change in government as a case of “regime revenge”.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray, in an order dated November 13, held that the government’s decision to cancel the sale after accepting the entire consideration was arbitrary and violated Article 14 of the Constitution.
The court observed that the government could not withdraw from a commitment that a citizen had acted upon to his detriment merely because the political dispensation had changed.
The property, purchased by the Mizoram government in 1973, was subsequently used as Mizoram House. In May 2023, the state’s General Administration Department initiated an e-tender-cum-e-auction process to sell the property.
Excel Vincom emerged as the highest bidder and entered into an agreement for sale with the government on October 6, 2023. The company paid the entire consideration of approximately Rs 38.29 crore, including applicable penal interest.
However, on January 4, 2024, the government cancelled the tender process, citing public interest and representations from the Kolkata Mizo Students and the Calcutta Mizo Welfare Association, which referred to the property’s historical and sentimental significance.
Excel Vincom challenged the cancellation before the High Court. A Single Judge set aside the government’s decision and directed it to execute and register the sale deed in accordance with the agreement. The Mizoram government subsequently appealed against the order before the Division Bench.
In its appeal, the state argued that the tender conditions reserved its right to cancel the process before execution of the conveyance and that the company had not acquired ownership of the property. It also cited public interest, alleged non-compliance with government financial rules and the availability of alternative remedies through arbitration and civil proceedings.
The company maintained that a binding agreement had been concluded after extensive correspondence and payment of the full consideration. It argued that the government had failed to establish any overriding public interest to justify cancelling the transaction.
The Division Bench acknowledged that the tender conditions reserved the government’s right to cancel the process before execution of the conveyance. However, it held that such powers could not be exercised arbitrarily, unfairly or unreasonably, particularly in view of the state’s obligations under Article 14 of the Constitution.
The court noted that the government had accepted the entire consideration and penal interest without reservation, exchanged drafts of the agreement and approved modifications to the proposed sale deed. Only execution and registration of the conveyance remained pending.
It also observed that the government had deferred the transaction until after the election and that the succeeding administration cancelled it without first entering into a dialogue with the company.
The Bench held that public interest could override private contractual interests, but such grounds had to be overwhelming and demonstrable. It found that the representations made by the two organisations did not establish sufficient public interest to justify cancelling a transaction that was nearing completion.
The court also noted that the government had neither alleged that the property was undervalued nor demonstrated that completing the sale would cause any loss to the public exchequer.
It further held that execution of the agreement and payment of the full consideration had created, at least in equity, a right in favour of the company to obtain the conveyance, while imposing a corresponding obligation on the government.
The Bench rejected the state’s argument that the company should have pursued arbitration or filed a civil suit for specific performance. It held that the availability of an alternative remedy did not prevent the High Court from exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, particularly when the challenged government action was alleged to be arbitrary and illegal.
The court also dismissed the government’s reliance on alleged violations of internal financial rules, observing that a third party dealing with the government was entitled to presume that its official acts had been regularly performed. It found no demonstrated breach of the applicable Business Rules that could invalidate the company’s accrued contractual rights.
Holding that the cancellation was unfair, unjust, arbitrary and contrary to Article 14, the Division Bench dismissed the Mizoram government’s appeal and upheld the direction to execute and register the sale deed.
The court granted the state eight weeks to comply with the direction and made no order as to costs.
The case, titled State of Mizoram and Others v. Excel Vincom Private Limited and Another (FMA 772 of 2024), was decided on November 13, 2026.
